Judge dismisses lawsuit filed by former OK Foods grower
OK Foods did not breach contract when it terminated contract with grower, judge rules
A federal judge in the Eastern District of Oklahoma has dismissed a poultry grower's breach of contract claim against OK Foods after the company severed ties with the grower amid concerns over animal welfare standards.
The company, located in Fort Smith, Arkansas, terminated its grower's agreement with Earl Oldham of Stigler, Oklahoma, just over a year into the three-year agreement following the drowning deaths of an estimated 19,000 broiler chickens during a May 2015 rainstorm, according to a news release from Baily Brauer PLLC, the law firm representing OK Foods. It was the second mass die-off in five years blamed on groundwater flooding at the farm, according to the law firm.
After realizing the water was rising in his three poultry houses, Oldham requested the company remove all chickens from his property, the law firm stated. Upon arrival, a company representative discovered that many of the chickens had already died. OK Foods took immediate steps to relocate the surviving chickens to a nearby poultry farm. After OK Foods notified Oldham that his contract would be terminated, Oldham filed a breach of contract suit.
The lawsuit dismissal follows a summary judgment motion filed by OK Foods' attorney Clayton Bailey of Bailey Brauer PLLC. In granting the summary judgment, the court threw out Oldham's claims seeking nearly $330,000 in lost-profit damages.
"Mr. Oldham in essence moved to terminate the contract with his demands to remove the broilers from the farm, something OK Foods was more than willing to oblige," said Bailey.
Contract termination in accordance with OK Foods policies
Bailey noted that the swift termination of the contract was in accordance with animal welfare policies implemented by OK Foods CEO and President Trent Goins, Vice President of Live Operations Gary Hogue and Director of Broiler and Hatchery Operations Kelly Garris.
"OK Foods did not agree with the conditions found at this farm, and it was not something that could be tolerated. The operator's own words, actions and inactions in effect invalidated his grower agreement. OK Foods simply formalized that termination," said Bailey. "Animal welfare is something OK Foods takes seriously. OK Foods' live operations team is ensuring that OK Foods' chickens are raised ethically and efficiently, and that the company's customers receive top-quality products."
In addition to Bailey, OK Foods was represented by Niki Cung of Kutak Rock LLP, Fayetteville, Arkansas.