Worlds apart on H5N1
Indonesia has announced the death of its 91st human victim but remains reluctant to share vital information with WHO.
26 November 2007; United Kingdom— Just 48 hours after confirmation of H5N1, the sub-type of highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) in United Kingdom (UK) poultry on 13 November 2007, more than one thousand related items had appeared on the worldwide web. Indonesia simultaneously announced its 113th human case and 91st fatality – a 31-year-old man from Riau province on Sumatra – from the same virus sub-type. The disease had been ‘picking off’ people with increasing regularity in Indonesia. The victim’s wife looks like the 114th case.
H5N1 is endemic right across Indonesia and the government has virtually ceased to notice, let alone identify, record and report H5N1 in poultry. Most human cases there are announced with the same fatalistic phrase, ‘The patient/victim had no previous contact with sick or dead fowl’.
Indonesia has not reported a single outbreak in poultry since September 2006. Its last report logged with World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) was for July to September 2006 and covered outbreaks in Sulawesi and Irian Jaya. There was no mention of infected poultry in Java or Sumatra where almost all human cases and fatalities have occurred. Since the start of 2007, there have been 38 human cases in Indonesia, of which 33 have been fatal.
Virologists, veterinarians and doctors around the world remain concerned about mutation and genetic re-assortment that could spark a human H5N1 pandemic. The poultry industry is clearly worried about loss of stock, but the public at large – especially in the West – are more concerned about the human dimension. This is why an isolated outbreak in eastern England generates so much media interest.
Given the extent of modern international travel any potential effect of isolated European outbreaks in poultry on a potential human pandemic is largely academic. There is a ‘time bomb’ is ticking away in Indonesia where the H5N1 is endemic and the authorities appear to have been defeated by the virus in poultry is concerned.World Health Organization (WHO) needs to know what is happening to the H5N1 virus in Indonesia as it attempts to track its evolution and development in order to develop matching human vaccine. Representatives from governments around the world attended a crucially important meeting at WHO headquarters in Geneva (20-23 November 2007). Its aim was to revive the global system of virus sample sharing that was virtually destroyed earlier this year following Indonesian-led protests on sample sharing and vaccine availability. According to Reuters, Indonesia has sent only two samples from H5N1-infected people in 2007, while there have been 38 human cases in the country so far this year. Indonesia and its allies claim that samples they send to the WHO-run Global Influenza Surveillance Network (GISN) are used to develop patented diagnostic tests and vaccines that they cannot afford.